Important: This isn't about asking for payment on platforms
Exchange platforms like TrustedHousesitters and Nomador explicitly prohibit paid arrangements. Asking for payment through these platforms can get you excluded. This guide is about transitioning to paid work outside of those platforms – through direct bookings, repeat clients who approach you, or directories like ours where paid work is the norm.
How housesitting evolved
Platforms like TrustedHousesitters and Nomador created something remarkable: a way for pet owners to find trusted care for free, while sitters got free accommodation. It was a genuine exchange. Millions of successful sits later, the model clearly works.
But something interesting has happened. Many sitters who started on these platforms five, eight, ten years ago – people with 30, 50, 100+ glowing reviews – are increasingly looking for paid work. Not because the free-exchange model failed them, but because their circumstances evolved. And recent changes like TrustedHousesitters introducing per-sit booking fees have accelerated this conversation.
Why sitters make the shift
Experience has value
After years of caring for hundreds of pets, handling emergencies, managing complex situations – these sitters have become genuinely skilled. Housesitting was traditionally a paid profession, and many experienced sitters feel their expertise warrants compensation.
Sustainability matters
Free accommodation is valuable, but sitters still have travel costs, insurance, food, and life expenses. For those housesitting regularly, the economics eventually become challenging. Paid work makes the lifestyle sustainable long-term.
Commitment runs both ways
When money changes hands, both parties are more invested. Paid sitters are less likely to cancel. Homeowners are more likely to communicate clearly about expectations. The arrangement feels more professional for everyone. A written agreement helps formalise this.
Life stage changes
Digital nomads settle down but still want to housesit. Retirees want purpose and modest income, not just free stays. Career freelancers need to value their time. The “travel for free” motivation shifts to “get rewarded for expertise” – and going paid through a directory like ours becomes a natural next step — especially when you're building repeat client relationships.
What this means for homeowners
This shift creates real advantages if you're willing to pay:
The “hobby vs professional” question
In housesitting communities, there's an ongoing debate. Some homeowners see free-exchange sitters as “hobbyists” and prefer to pay for “professionals.” Others have had wonderful experiences with unpaid sitters.
The reality is more nuanced. Payment doesn't automatically equal quality. What matters is experience, references, and fit. Many experienced sitters on free-exchange platforms are exceptional. And some paid sitters are mediocre.
The real question: Are you getting someone with a proven track record, clear communication, and genuine investment in doing excellent work? Payment can help ensure commitment, but verified experience is what really matters.
Free-exchange still has its place
Free-exchange works well for
- • Budget-conscious homeowners
- • Flexible dates with good lead time
- • Desirable locations sitters want to visit
- • Straightforward pet care needs
- • Building experience (both sides)
Paid housesitting works well for
- • Choosing a specific, proven sitter
- • Peak holiday periods
- • Complex or medical pet needs
- • Guaranteed commitment
- • Building a repeat relationship
The bottom line
The housesitting landscape is maturing. Experienced sitters have options, and many are choosing to be compensated for their expertise. For homeowners, this creates an opportunity: access to highly experienced, verified sitters who are invested in your satisfaction.
If you've struggled with the lottery of free-exchange applications, or you want to build a reliable ongoing relationship with a proven sitter, paid housesitting might be worth considering. Ready? Build a Reputable Profile.
Rate Negotiation Guide for Sitters
For when homeowners approach you directly about paid work. Calculate your rate, prepare conversation scripts, and handle common objections with confidence.